Guides

How to convert any yeast bread recipe to sourdough

Got a favourite recipe that calls for instant yeast? You can run it on your starter instead. Swap the yeast, rebalance the flour and water, stretch the clock, done.

Recipes
How-to
Conversion
Finn Glas
Finn GlasCo-Founder + Engineering
·April 18, 2026·
3 min read

Key takeaways

Replace the commercial yeast with about 20% of the flour weight as starter.
Subtract the starter's flour and water from the recipe to keep hydration right.
Expect the rise to take hours, not minutes; ferment to the dough, not the clock.
Step by step
1

Remove the yeast, add starter

Use ripe starter at ~20% of the flour weight.

2

Subtract starter's flour + water

100g starter = 50g flour + 50g water to remove.

3

Rise to doubled, not by the clock

Expect 4 to 12 hours; cold-proof overnight if you like.

4

Log it for next time

Starter %, rise times, result, so bake two improves.

1. Swap the yeast for starter

Drop the packet of instant or active-dry yeast entirely. In its place, add ripe, active starter at roughly 20% of the recipe's total flour weight, a good default. So a recipe with 500g flour gets about 100g of starter. More starter means a faster (and slightly tangier) rise; less means slower. You can tune it later, but 20% is a reliable starting point that works for most loaves.

2. Rebalance flour and water

The starter you just added brought its own flour and water, so subtract those from the recipe or the dough will be too wet. A 100%-hydration starter is half flour, half water by weight: 100g of starter = 50g flour + 50g water. So reduce the recipe's flour by 50g and its water by 50g. Skip this step and you've effectively added 100g of extra liquid-and-flour the recipe wasn't written for, which is a common reason a first conversion comes out slack.

Work in grams, not cups

The subtract-the-starter math only works if you weigh. Cup measures hide the flour-to-water ratio that the whole conversion depends on. A cheap kitchen scale is the single best upgrade for sourdough, and it makes converting recipes trivial.

3. Stretch the timeline (a lot)

This is the biggest mental shift. Commercial yeast raises dough in 1 to 2 hours; a starter takes 4 to 12 depending on its strength and your kitchen temperature. So wherever the original recipe says "let rise 1 hour", read it as "let rise until roughly doubled", which will take much longer. Ferment to the dough's state, not the recipe's clock. Many bakers also move the final proof to the fridge overnight, which fits sourdough's slower pace and deepens the flavour.

4. Log the conversion so round two is better

Your first conversion is an experiment, and experiments are only useful if you record them. Note the starter percentage you used, how long each rise actually took, and how the loaf turned out. The second bake of the same recipe is where conversion really pays off, you adjust one variable from a known baseline instead of starting from scratch. Sourdough Tracker keeps that bake-to-bake thread so a converted recipe gets reliably better instead of being a fresh gamble each time.

FAQ

Frequently asked

Try Sourdough Tracker

Free plan, no credit card. We host in Germany. You can export and delete everything self-serve.

Finn Glas

Written by

Finn Glas

Co-Founder + Engineering

Finn is one of the Co-Founders. He owns the engineering side, the infrastructure, and most of the late-night fixes that ship before anyone notices.

finn.glas at aicuflow dot comLinkedInWebsite